← Blog

Best Paint By Numbers: Questions to Ask First

Best Paint By Numbers: Questions to Ask First

The best paint by numbers kits are made for slow evenings. You put on a podcast, make some tea, and fill in tiny shapes until a picture shows up. It's calming in a way that's hard to explain until you try it.

But not every kit is a good one. Some kits arrive as a joy to work on, while others show up with half the paint pots dried into little hockey pucks, so check reviews for complaints about dried paint before you buy. So before you pick one, here are the questions I ask myself now. They'll save you some frustration and maybe a wasted afternoon.

Short on time? Our top picks: Paint by Number Kits from Crayola, Paintworks, Plaid and Winnie's Picks. See all picks

Best Paint By Numbers: Questions to Ask First. The list includes What canvas size?, What paint quality?, Are brushes included?.

1. What canvas size fits my time?

Big canvases look amazing in photos. They also take a long time. A large kit with hundreds of tiny sections can stretch over weeks if you only paint an hour or two at a time. That's fine if you love long projects, but it can feel like homework if you don't.

For a first kit, I'd go smaller. You'll finish it, feel good about it, and learn how you like to work. A first kit that is a mid-sized landscape can get tiring, since large areas of sky may start to drag somewhere around week three. Lesson learned.

Tip: Look at the number of sections, not just the size. Two kits can be the same size, but one might have far more tiny areas to fill. Close-up photos usually show this.

2. How good is the paint in a paint by numbers kit?

Paint quality is where cheap kits often fall short. You might get thin paint that needs three coats to cover the numbers, or pots that aren't sealed well. Either one turns a relaxing evening into a fussy one.

The seller's page won't always tell you much here. Reviews and comments from buyers will. You can skip the star rating and read what people actually say. Look for words like "dried out," "streaky," or "ran out of paint." If several people mention the same problem, believe them.

Tip: Once you open the kit, keep the lids tightly closed when you're not using a color. A dab of water can sometimes loosen paint that's just starting to thicken, but don't count on it saving a pot that's fully dry.

Free gift: get the Blank Board Game Board and 10 Card Templates when you join our email list. Get it free

3. Are brushes included, and are they any good?

Most kits come with brushes. Some come with nice ones. Many come with a small set that sheds bristles or splays out after one evening. Check the product list so you know what you're getting.

Honestly, I think the included brushes are a bit overrated as a selling point. Separate fine-tip brushes, such as a set from Artecho, can make the tiny sections much easier. If a kit is great in every other way but the brushes look flimsy, I'd still buy it.

Tip: A fine detail brush is worth having for small areas. Rinse it well between colors and don't leave it standing in the water cup, which bends the tip.

4. How clear are the numbers and lines?

This one matters more than people think. If the printed lines are faint or the numbers are tiny and crowded, you'll spend a lot of time squinting. Some kits also print dark lines that show through light paint, which can leave the finished piece looking a little messy.

Look at the close-up photos of the blank canvas if the seller shows them. Buyer photos are even better, because they show the real thing, not a polished product shot. You want crisp lines and numbers you can read without leaning in too close.

Tip: Paint near a good lamp or a window. A simple magnifier can help too, especially on detailed kits. Your eyes will thank you every time you remember to use one.

Best Paint By Numbers: Questions to Ask First. A short list of 6 tips with a link to read more.

5. Is a frame included with the canvas, or will I need one?

Adult paint by numbers canvas kits come in a few styles. Some have a canvas already stretched on a wooden frame. Others arrive rolled up, which means you'll need to stretch or frame it yourself if you want to hang it. Neither is wrong, but it's good to know before you buy.

Rolled canvases can have creases that take a while to flatten. Pre-framed ones are easier to paint on since the surface stays tight. If you're giving the finished piece as a gift, or ordering a paint by numbers custom photo kit from a marketplace like Etsy, framing matters even more.

Tip: If your canvas arrives rolled, lay it flat under a few heavy books for a day or two before you start. It helps the creases relax.

Quick side note: if you like making things for game night too, you can grab our free Blank Board Game Board and 10 Card Templates when you join the email list.

6. What's the return policy for a custom or personalized kit?

Nobody plans to return a craft kit. But if paint arrives dry or pieces are missing, you'll want to know your options. Check the seller's terms before you order, not after something goes wrong.

Some sellers will send replacement paint pots if you contact them. Others won't take back an opened kit at all. The policy is usually on the product page or in the store's help section, so take a minute to look.

Tip: Open your kit and check everything when it arrives, even if you're not starting right away. Count the pots, look at the canvas, and test a lid or two. Problems are easier to sort out early.

7. Does the picture actually excite me?

This sounds obvious, but it's easy to buy a kit because it was on sale or looked "nice enough." You'll be staring at this image for hours. If you don't love it, you'll probably stop halfway.

Pick a picture paint by numbers design you'd be happy to hang on your wall. A pet paint by numbers portrait, a favorite place, a modern paint by numbers pattern, whatever makes you want to sit down and start. Interest carries you through the boring parts, like that endless sky I mentioned.

Tip: I like to jot down notes on each kit I finish: how long it took, what I liked, what I'd do differently.

8. How will I fit it into my week?

This isn't about the kit itself, but it matters. Paint by numbers works best when you have a spot where you can leave it out. Packing up wet paint and brushes every night gets old fast.

A corner of a desk or a folding table works fine. Lay down some newspaper or an old placemat. Then you can sit down for twenty minutes whenever you want, without setup getting in the way.

Tip: Paint one color at a time across the whole canvas. It saves paint, keeps your brush cleaner, and gives you little wins as each color is done.

Paint by numbers kits and tools worth a look

Here are a few well-known kits and helpful add-ons to browse while you decide. Each one suits a slightly different kind of painter.

Paint by Number Kits from Crayola

Crayola makes craft products many people already know, which can feel reassuring for a first try. It suits beginners and families painting together. Check the canvas size and the number of sections before you choose.

Paintworks

Paintworks is a long-running paint by numbers brand found at many craft and hobby shops. It suits people who like to see a kit in person before buying. Check what is included in the box, since contents can differ between kits.

Plaid

Plaid is a craft brand known for paint and hobby kits. It suits crafters who like buying from a name they recognize. Check the finished size and the level of detail so it matches the time you have.

Winnie's Picks

Winnie's Picks sells paint by numbers kits for adults with many picture styles. It suits anyone who wants a wide choice of designs. Read recent buyer comments about paint and canvas quality first.

Etsy

Etsy is a marketplace where independent sellers offer custom photo and pet portrait kits. It suits readers who want a personalized gift. Check each seller's return policy and how they handle damaged or dried paint.

Liquitex

Liquitex is a respected acrylic paint brand. It suits painters who want to mix a replacement color or touch up a run-out pot. Check that the shade is close to your kit's color before painting over any numbers.

Artecho

Artecho sells art supplies, including brush sets. It suits painters who want finer tips for tiny sections. Look at the brush shapes and sizes listed to be sure they suit small detail work.

Check current plans and prices on each brand's own site before you buy.

FAQ

Are paint-by-numbers kits good for beginners?

Yes, and the best paint by numbers for adults are made for beginners too. You don't need any art skills, just patience and decent light. Start with a smaller kit so you can finish it and enjoy the result.

What if I run out of a color?

Contact the seller first, since some will send extra pots. You can also try mixing a close match with craft acrylics, such as those from Liquitex. It may not be exact, but small differences are rarely noticeable.

Do I need to varnish my finished painting?

You don't have to. Some people like a coat of varnish to protect the paint and even out the shine. If you try it, follow the directions on the varnish label and test a small corner first.

How long does a kit take to finish?

It depends on the size, the detail, and how often you paint. A small kit might take a few evenings, while a large detailed one can take weeks. There's no rush, which is kind of the point.

If you're ready to set up a cozy hobby night, start by grabbing the free Blank Board Game Board and 10 Card Templates from the sign-up box. Then take a look at the Gaming & Hobbies Journal and the Game Night Calculator and Tracker Spreadsheet below this post if you'd like a simple way to keep your projects and game nights organized.

Free gift: get the Blank Board Game Board and 10 Card Templates when you join our email list. Get it free
Tip: Prices and details change. Check the seller's page.

Printables and tools that can help

Game Night Calculator and Tracker Spreadsheet

A spreadsheet with a summary page and a calculator sheet. Works in Excel and Google...

See details

Gaming & Hobbies Journal

A 100-page printable PDF. Print it at home or fill it in on...

See details